Indigo Girls' 'What Was Really Me' stands as a poignant exploration of vulnerability and self-acceptance, delivered with the band's signature acoustic intimacy. Recorded during their prolific period in the late 1990s, the track exemplifies the duo's ability to weave personal narrative with universal themes of emotional honesty. The song features a stripped-down arrangement that highlights Amy and Emmy Woo's harmonies and storytelling prowess, characteristic of their folk-rock and indie-folk repertoire. It reflects a time when the group was deeply engaged in addressing social issues alongside intimate relationship dynamics, creating a sound that resonated deeply with audiences seeking authenticity in their music.