It should have been you stands as a defining track from The Waterboys' self-titled 1983 debut, capturing the band's early fusion of rock energy with Celtic folk sensibilities. Released during a period of intense experimentation, the recording showcases the group's ability to blend driving rhythms with atmospheric textures that would later characterize their signature Big Music sound. The song reflects the raw, urgent songwriting style that established the band's reputation in the British alternative scene. As part of their initial catalogue, it highlights the artistic vision that propelled them toward subsequent critical acclaim and a diverse discography spanning decades. The track remains a testament to their early commitment to merging traditional influences with modern rock instrumentation.