Juliana Hatfield delivers a hauntingly intimate performance on 'It Should've Been You,' a track that exemplifies her signature blend of indie rock and emotional vulnerability. Recorded for the 2004 album *In Exile Deo*, the song showcases her distinctive vocal style, characterized by a raw, conversational tone that cuts through the sparse instrumentation. The recording reflects the introspective nature of her work during the mid-2000s, drawing upon themes of regret and lost connections that have become central to her discography. Hatfield's ability to convey deep personal sentiment through minimalistic arrangements defines this piece, positioning it as a standout moment in her career that resonates with listeners seeking authentic, unpolished musical expression.