Nickel Creek's rendition of 'Don't Fence Me In' appears on their 2002 album Little Cowpoke, a record that marked a distinct departure from their earlier, more intricate folk arrangements. The band, consisting of siblings Sara and Sean Watkins alongside Chris Thile, embraced a looser, more traditional country and western aesthetic for this project. This cover of the classic Cole Porter standard fits seamlessly within the album's thematic exploration of the American West, showcasing the group's ability to reinterpret established material through their signature instrumental prowess. The recording highlights the ensemble's dynamic interplay and their capacity to blend bluegrass instrumentation with broader Americana influences, solidifying their reputation as versatile interpreters of the genre.