How Could You Believe Me When I Told You That I Loved You
Danny Kaye · Other Songs - Danny Kaye
When you know I've been a liar all my life
I've had that reputation since I was a youth
You must have been insane to think I'd tell you the truth
How could you believe me when I said we'd marry
When you know I'd rather hang than have a wife
I know I said I'd make you mine
But who would know that you would go for that old line
How could you believe me when I said I love you
When you know I've been a liar
Nothing but a liar, all my doggone cheatin' life
(Girl) You said you would love me long, and never would do me wrong
And faithful you'd always be
(Boy) Oh, baby, you must be loony to trust a lower
than low two time like me
(Girl) You said I'd have everything, a beautiful diamond ring
A bungalow by the sea
(Boy)You're really naive to ever believe a full of baloney phoney like me
(Girl) Say! How about the time you went to Indiana
(Boy) I was lyin' I was down in Alabama!
(Girl) You said you had some business you had to complete
(Boy) What I was doin' I would be a cad to repeat
(Girl) What about the evenings you were with your mother
(Boy) I was romping with another honey lamb
(Girl) To think you swore our love was real
(Boy) But, baby, let us not forget, that I'm a heel
How could you believe me when I said I love you
When you know I've been a liar, nothing but a liar
About How Could You Believe Me When I Told You That I Loved You
Danny Kaye's "How Could You Believe Me When I Told You That I Loved You" stands as a quintessential example of his unique ability to blend musical comedy with heartfelt sentiment. Recorded during the golden age of Hollywood musicals, the track showcases Kaye's signature style, where his infectious, slightly off-key vocals and rapid-fire delivery create an immediate connection with the audience. The song, often associated with his film work, exemplifies the era's emphasis on lighthearted romance and slapstick humor, utilizing a catchy melody that has ensured its enduring popularity. Beyond its comedic roots, the recording highlights Kaye's versatility as a performer, capable of delivering both musical wit and genuine emotion. While frequently linked to his filmography, the song's standalone appeal lies in its ability to evoke nostalgia and joy, making it a staple in his extensive discography. Its continued presence in live performances and compilations underscores its status as a beloved piece of American musical theater history, reflecting the broader cultural impact of Kaye's contributions to the genre.