The Civil Wars delivered a haunting interpretation of the classic pop standard on their 2011 debut album, Barton Hollow. Known for their intimate harmonies and acoustic arrangements, the duo transformed the upbeat original into a somber, stripped-back ballad that highlights their signature vocal interplay. This recording stands as a testament to their ability to reimagine established material within their own distinct folk and Americana framework. The track complements the album's cohesive atmosphere, showcasing the group's skill in balancing delicate instrumentation with emotionally resonant performances. As part of their critically acclaimed early discography, this version remains a notable example of their collaborative artistry and enduring appeal in the modern folk landscape.